Breyers Ice Cream Complaints and Reviews

Had an experience with Breyers Ice Cream?   Submit review ›
Breyers Ice Cream
Main address: 920 Sylvan Avenue, 2nd Floor 07632 Englewood Cliffs NJ
1-866-204-9750, ,
  • 125+14 mobile complaints
  • $2.8K claimed losses
  • $20 average
Had an experience with Breyers Ice Cream?
Submit review › Submit review ›

Very disappointed in the ice cream. I just bought the girl scout cookie ice cream and my husband opens it (2 hrs after buying it) & its totally freezer burnt. (Mind you, none of the other frozen items I bought are freezer burnt?) Questioning the shipping methods of this brand? Add comment

I ate one of the Breyers blasts--Reese ' s pm blasts. .the fudge took over the taste. When peanuts are the first ingredient, I expect that too stand out not fudge! I will not have it again. It does not taste like the candy at all. Add comment


  • Nov 21
  • Food Vendors
  • Palm Bay, Florida
  • Caramel Praline Crunch
  • 1

What Happened to the Breyers Caramel Praline Crunch Ice Cream? I loved the Caramel Praline Crunch and I can't find it anymore at any of the stores in my area. It was a flavor I don't see in any other Manufacturer or Ice Cream. I don't eat very many sweets but that was one treat that I allowed myself to indulge in occasionally. The only other I like is the Creamy Vanilla but that doesn't hit my... Read more

Was this review helpful? 0 0

Your packaging on your Gelato breaks and cracks rendering the ice cream open to air and contamination. I've had three crack and its annoying and unsanitary. I've purchased in Safeway and Wal-Mart. Add comment

Not a big deal, but had it for the 1st time and thought that it lacked the rich flavor that I was expecting. Looking at these reviews explains it. A waste of calories for me. Add comment

I bought breyers strawberry cheesecake and was not happy with this product very few cheesecake bites and strawberry syrup taste nasty Add comment

Even in the mid 80’s there were issues with the brand. It tasted like sand and I stopped buying it. Now its worse. I'm sorry I wasted money on a pint! Add comment


  • Oct 09
  • Food Vendors
  • Shreveport, Louisiana
  • Ice Cream Taste
  • 2
  • 2
  • 28

Breyers ice cream was GREAT. I would pay more to keep the old formula. But with these new formulas contain things that should not be. The new owners know nothing about making ice cream; and not much more on taste! Read more

Was this review helpful? 0 0


  • Oct 07
  • Food Vendors
  • Lockport, New York
  • Ice Cream Taste
  • 35

I bought 3/$10 today at the grocery store because it was cheap. This ice cream is awful! Tastes like frozen sugary milk and the texture is dry and crumbly. The flavor I first opened was Strawberry but you wouldnt know that by the taste. Should've been called "Sugar" and the strawberries in it were limited. Would rather have purchased the cheap brand! I will never buy Breyers again. Quite a... Read more

Was this review helpful? 0 0
You are reading about Breyers Ice Cream.
Filing a new complaint about